/ / / / / /

Surprise! TSA's New Fake-Busting ID Scanners Not Quite Working As Promised

June 20, 2012 at 3:06 PM | by | Comment (1)

You'll recall that last April we gave you a heads up on TSA's new ID scanners, which are designed to speed up security and close a notorious and well-known loophole in American airport security. The so-called "CAT-BPSS" (Credential Authentication Technology—Boarding Pass Scanning System) scanners were supposed to bust fakes more quickly and efficiently than humans could. That was supposed to be "fantastic" for getting people through checkpoints.

We complained that it wouldn't really speed things up since security bottlenecks happen at the metal detectors and scanners, and not at the ID checks. But we assumed that the scanners worked, and they plugged a hole that needed plugging, so overall we were pretty positive about the roll out. You know what they say about assuming, right?

Turns out the scanners pretty much don't work and that Congressional lawmakers are kind pissed off about that. A report by the Government Accountability Office concluded that the system wasn't checking IDs against state and federal databases and wasn't reducing costs and it wasn't doing a whole bunch of other things. It turns out that TSA never did a cost-benefit analysis to check whether what it was promising about the technology was actually true, which is something you'd expect for a system supposed to cost $130 million and last 20 years (something else the GAO also didn't totally believe).

All of this is beginning to seem eerily familiar. TSA officials got enamored with some new multimillion dollar technology that was supposed to automate some part of a checkpoint. The agency told everyone that its people are doing due diligence, making sure the new technology worked, and so on. Instead what actually happened is that the technology got rushed into airports without even basic tests.

With full-body scanners, it looks very much as if well-funded scanner lobbies pushed the agency into a multimillion dollar boondoggle, until eventually an entire new kind of scanner had to be purchased. Who knows what we'll find out about the ID scanners?

[Photo: niiicedave / Flickr]

Comment (1)

Post a Comment

The problem

So our business - AvidBiometrics.com has been selling portable (like those found in restaurants and bars).  

The thing is, you can validate if it's a real ID, but there is still a risk that it could be a real ID of someone else.

You really have to be careful and it's a shame that they spent so much money without troubleshooting the technology first.

These work great for small businesses, but the TSA needs to have their game together when it comes to public safety!

Join the conversation!

Not a member? .