Is the Poor Economy Saving Our Skylines?
6/12/2008 at 5:10 PM
Tags: Skyscrapers, Architecture, Buildings, Dubai Travel (all tags)
The Western World may be losing it's dominance in the neverending skyline wars, but that might not be such a bad thing for American and European city-dwellers. German newsmagazine Der Spiegel reports that as the credit crisis is halting ambitious real estate projects in the States, emerging powers such as China, Dubai and Russia are building bigger and crazier skyscrapers than ever.
This skyline boom may be providing these nouveau riche nations with status symbols, but much of the construction is being criticized by architecture experts as environmentally and aesthetically harmful.
Public opinion in many places seems to agree with the experts' contention that modern skyscrapers are ugly. The Spiegel article cites European architects who see a positive side to the poor economy because it will allow the continent to preserve it's "enduring cityscapes."
Similarly in New York, Frank Gehry's $4 billion Atlantic Yards project in Brooklyn is stalling thank to money troubles, which must be a relief to the area residents who have protested the plan since it's inception. Another major New York landmark, the proposed Freedom Tower, is also way behind schedule, but it's not like those designs have been highly anticipated by the locals.
The distaste for new developments among Western architects may be bitter posturing. It's easy to dismiss modern skyscrapers when you can't afford to build any. On the other hand, it's not hard to see why some of these buildings are said to be in questionable taste. The futuristic glossy towers do have a certain homogeneous and sanitized quality to them. That might have something to do with the fact that, as Spiegel points out:
One of the most ironic aspects of this development is that, in many cases, it is the West's leading architects who are driving the transition.
In other words, the lack of variety in the skyscraper boom may be a result of the fact that it's driven by a small clique of influential architects and their imitators. A poor economy is nothing to be happy about, but it's clear that local character can be a casualty of a construction boom. If you can't afford to travel this summer, at least you can hope that things will still be the same in Paris or New York by the time you get there.
Related Stories:
· Battle of the Skyscrapers [Der Spiegel, via]
· Architecture coverage [Jaunted]
[Photos, left to right: "Sliced Porosity Block," Chengdu, China; Burj Dubai; Crystal Island, Moscow]
Leave a Comment
Not yet a member? Click here to become a member.
Already a member? Login below: